Poverty in paradise: The dark side of Indonesia's new tourism hope

2017-09-26 10:40
Post a comment 0

Istock Photo

Raja Ampat, Indonesia - A tableau of white sandy beaches, colourful coral reefs and turquoise water, the islands of Raja Ampat are set to be Indonesia's next tourism hot spot - but locals fear the government is failing both them and the environment in its development push.

READ: Quick guide: Indonesia

The darker side 

Stretching across 67 000 square kilometers in Indonesia's far east, the picture-perfect islands might be as close to paradise as visitors can find.

"It's amazing. We've been to millions of islands and I would say it's the most beautiful one," Canadian Angelika Redweik-Leung says at a lookout above the Pianemo island group.

Raja Ampat - which means four kings - is made up of 1500 islands and is home to about 1400 varieties of fish and 600 species of coral, making it one of the most bio-diverse marine habitats on earth.

Indonesia's government is intent on turning the area into a tourism hotspot - building hotels, restaurants and investing in new harbours.

Location: Wayag, Raja Ampat Credit: @abdussalamg

A post shared by Raja Ampat (@rajaampatislands) on

But on a palm-fringed island about two hours boat ride from Raja Ampat's capital Waisai, villagers still live in simple huts that lack electricity and clean water, while the nearest high school is scores of miles away.

Locals told AFP they had seen no improvements to their lives despite the dramatic rise in visitors. According to government, estimates around 15 000 tourists now come to the area each year - up from less than 5 000 in 2010.

"They've hurt us indigenous people. They took our land, our water and our forest. We feel betrayed," Paul Mayor, chief of the island's Byak Betew tribe, says of the government's tourism drive.

"That's our land, our ocean, which now it's a world-class tourist destination, but we've gained nothing from the influx of tourists," he adds.


READ: Indonesian escapes to suit your budget

Mayor also criticised authorities for failing to properly protect the area's unique ecosystem, pointing to a catastrophic cruise ship crash in March, which damaged 13 500 square meters of pristine coral reef.

The 4 200-ton Caledonian Sky ran aground near the island of Kri carrying 102 passengers and 79 crew, but half a year later no one has been held accountable.

 "We are still poor" 

Researchers from the University of Papua, who assessed the impact of the accident, says restoring the damaged reef could cost as much as $16.2 million. The head of tourism for Raja Ampat, Yusdi Lamatenggo, says the company operating the boat, Noble Caledonia - will be summoned to appear in court soon but so far they have not accepted responsibility or paid any damages.

In the meantime, he told AFP, steps were being taken to prevent further accidents by establishing clearly demarcated cruise ship routes and world-class harbors.

But the accident has fueled feelings of mistrust and exclusion often felt by Papua's indigenous Melanesian population. The resource-rich region was annexed by Jakarta in 1969 and most Papuans feel they have not been given an even share of its natural riches.

READ: 8 Things to do in Bali (again and again)

The military retains heavy influence in the region and regularly stifles dissent.

After taking office in 2014, president Joko Widodo pledged to speed up development in Papua, but many locals insist they have been forgotten.

"There has been no change," Ariel Fakdawer, head of Saukabu village in Raja Ampat told AFP.

"The yearly Raja Ampat festival, for example, attracts thousands of tourists but we gain nothing from that. We are still poor, but the organisers of such festivals, outsiders, they have made a fortune," he adds.

Indigenous groups say they need communication satellites, electricity, better infrastructure, and the right to govern themselves by customary law.

"The government never fulfils our needs because they don't understand what we want," chief Mayor says.

"I believe the government has to approach us by bearing in mind our cultural needs. They have to talk to us indigenous people," he insisted.

But not everyone is against the rush to open up Raja Ampat to the world.

Villager Medzke Karoswaf says "This is a modern world. We cannot live isolated like in a cave forever. We have to be open-minded. Like it or not, we don't live alone in this world."

What to read next on Traveller24

- Private jet goes off Istanbul runway, catches fire

- How affordable are skiing holidays for South Africans, really? 

- Bombs away! How to get through airport security smoothly